Raw Farm-Fresh Colby Cheese

Enjoy the smooth, creamy flavor of our Colby Cheese, handcrafted in small batches using raw, unpasteurized whole milk from trusted local farms. Perfect for snacking, melting into sandwiches, or elevating your favorite dishes, this mild and melt-in-your-mouth cheese is a versatile favorite for every occasion.

• Made with raw whole milk – unpasteurized for richer flavor

• Contains only natural ingredients – no preservatives or artificial additives

• Aged 60 days for balanced flavor and texture

• Pure and natural, perfect for cheese boards, burgers, and cooking

Product Size: Approx. 6 oz
Shelf Life: 3–4 weeks refrigerated after opening (store in an airtight container)
Ingredients: Raw Milk, Salt, Rennet, Culture

At Green Tomato Market, our farm-fresh cheeses are made in small batches and may not come with printed expiration dates like commercial brands. Because they’re free from preservatives, shelf life can vary by type and storage method. For aged cheeses like Colby, we recommend enjoying them within 2–3 weeks of opening for best flavor and quality.

Have questions about storage? We’re happy to help—just ask!

Free delivery with any fruit & veggie subscription.
Minimum order of $175 applies for standalone deliveries.